Two of the rarest varieties are the 1810 ‘Large Date - Small 5′ and 1810 ‘Small Date - Small 5′ Half Eagles. These are dramatically rarer than the corresponding 1810 ‘Large Date - Large 5′ and 1810 ‘Small date - Tall 5′ varieties. Does this sound confusing? It should. Many coin collectors, including some who are very advanced, are puzzled by the rarity and significance of these varieties, and fairly wonder whether these are worth bothering with at all. The topic here is the rarity and importance of the 1810 ‘Small Date - Small 5′ $5 gold coin.
Half Eagles are $5 gold coins. An 1810 ‘Small Date - Small 5′ Half Eagle has ‘made the news’ in a big way. On Aug. 5, Stack’s auctioned one for $126,500, undoubtedly an auction record for this variety. The previous record for an 1810 ‘Small Date - Small 5′ was set when Stack’s auctioned another for $65,550 in October 2005.
It is clear that the rage for early U.S. gold coins continues. This has been one of the hottest areas of coin markets for several years. Even so, an 1810 ‘Small Date - Small 5′ has never before sold for nearly as much, and it is not a coin that many collectors seek. It is important to discuss ‘what it is’ and why it sold for so much. Such an inquiry contributes to an understanding of the values of rare varieties and of early gold coins in general.
This 1810 Half Eagle has been graded AU-55 by the Professional Coin Grading Service (PCGS). Coins are graded on a scale from 01 to 70. There are four AU grades: 50, 53, 55, and 58. There are eleven MS grades, all increments from 60 to 70 inclusive. The PCGS and the Numismatic Guaranty Corp. (NGC) have never assigned a grade above 62 to an 1810 ‘Small Date - Small 5′ Half Eagle. So, a choice uncirculated example may not exist.
The 1810 ‘Small Date - Small 5′ is of the Bust Left Half Eagle type (1807-12). It is a short series. The following dates are certainly included: 1807, 1808/7, 1809/8, 1810 ‘Large Date,’ 1810 ‘Small Date,’ 1811 and 1812. Curiously, additional varieties relating to the denomination on the reverse (back of the coin) are included in most guides as if these are separate dates. As mentioned above, the 1810 ‘Large Date’ is divided into two dates, Large 5 and Small 5. Likewise, the 1810 ‘Small Date’ is so divided into ‘Small 5′ and ‘Tall 5′, as is the 1811. There is no doubt that these are additional die varieties. One die is used to strike the obverse (front of the coin) and a separate die is used to strike the reverse. An 1811 Half Eagle with a ‘Tall 5′ on the reverse was struck from a reverse die that is different from that used to strike an 1811 Half Eagle with a ‘Small 5′ on the reverse. How important is the distinction between different 5s?
The denomination of a Half Eagle is ‘Five Dollar Gold’ and the “5 D.” on the reverse indicates the denomination. Likewise, Draped Bust Half Cents (1800-08) have the denomination “1/200” on the reverse. All Type 2 Liberty Nickels have a Roman Numeral V along with the word “CENTS” on the reverse. Many design types of U.S. coins do not feature a denomination identifier. People who spend coins generally know their face value.
Is a minor difference in the denomination identifier really indicative of a separate date? It is true that the term ‘date’ refers to more than just the year on the coin.
Two coins of the same type and year may have different dates. An 1817 half dollar and an 1817/4 half dollar are of the same year, but are different dates. The term ‘date’ refers to a combination of the year, the characteristics of the digits, and the design type. It also relates to issues regarding Mint locations and mintmarks, but these will be ignored here as all Bust Left Half Eagles were struck in Philadelphia and none have mintmarks.
Small dates, large dates, and overdates, frequently indicate more than one date of the same type with the same year. Likewise, two different types with the same year will amount to at least two different dates. An 1807 Bust Right Half Eagle and an 1807 Bust Left Half Eagle are both different types and different dates.
Even a difference in the digits of a date, such as a fancy ‘2,’ may constitute an additional date relating to the same year. When an overdate (usually featuring one numeral punched over another) is easily seen, it is a distinct date. While the ‘year’ is part of the date, there is much more to the concept of the ‘date’ of a coin.